When the siblings Malena and Pablo go to sign the final papers giving the doctors permission to pull the plug on the machines keeping their father alive, a violent adventure begins. Despite Malena’s protests, Pablo insists that they should get to know their father first by visiting his old house. On the way there, they find a mysterious diary that describes in detail violent acts carried out in the very places they happen to be in. Trying to stop a chain of events that is dated several years into the past seems futile, but they are determined to do everything they can to prevent innocent people from having to pay with their lives over and over again…
I don’t know what it is about these Spanish films, or Argentina in this case, that appeals to me, but they repeatedly manage to create a sense of suspense and an interest in the story that few other films are capable of. You are never completely sure what is going to happen, and the twists come as surprises rather than predictable turns intended to make the story seem more interesting. Here, we are dealing with the real thing; every little twist has a purpose, and although it would be going too far to say that they all come as a total shock, there are certainly enough of them to make the unfolding events very interesting to follow.
I think part of the reason is that they don’t overdo things unnecessarily. The visual style is logical but not extravagant, and it is a little more static than what you are used to from more audience-friendly American films, and it relies more on the script than on astonishing effects. The effects that are there are very well done without being over-the-top, which also helps keep the film grounded and without any pretensions of being just another movie of the crowd. Furthermore, there is a historical background, which makes the story, even though it is supernatural in nature, possible to take completely seriously.
The moral and the question of what price is reasonable to pay to stop evil and dictatorship are pushed to the extreme. Without giving too much away, I think the protagonists of Aparecidos make absolutely the right decisions when it comes to the important questions. Sometimes it is more important to set things right than to think about your own safety; it can be worth intervening without considering either personal gain or what consequences it may have for you.
So this is a ghost story, but it is also more than that. The modern torture movie, with films like Saw and Hostel perhaps at the forefront, is definitely recognizable here and works very effectively. These scenes are surely made even more powerful by the fact that we actually have time to get to know the characters and grow fond of them. Watching someone suffer when you have a more personal connection to them is undeniably far more agonizing.
Perhaps not a super-innovative film all the way through, but certainly one of the most effective within its field.
